Do Diets Cause Eating Disorders?
Despite the common claims, the answer is probably not.
Do diets cause eating disorders?
I've seen the claim made many times online, so I looked into it. Surprisingly, best evidence seems to show that if anything, diets REDUCE the risk of eating disorders.
My new piece
gidmk.substack.com/p/do-diets-c...
05.03.2025 08:09
👍 25
🔁 9
💬 2
📌 1
The Rules of Anaesthesia are fantastic. Is there an equivalent for intensive care? If not, what would you include?
www.bmj.com/content/375/... would suggest: Believe nothing, trust no one, give oxygen.
12.02.2025 19:31
👍 30
🔁 10
💬 5
📌 3
Article by Dr Helen Salisbury.
Excerpt here:
Last week the Public Accounts Committee produced an excoriating report on the financial sustainability of the NHS in England.1 It criticised the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) and NHS England for their complacency, lack of ideas, failures in financial planning, and wildly optimistic assumptions about productivity.
The stated ambition of these bodies is to improve the nation’s health through three major shifts: from hospital to community, from analogue to digital, and from treatment to prevention—but how these changes will happen has yet to be elaborated.
The shift from treatment to prevention is arguably hampered by the DHSC’s view that providing more resources for prevention is “not a substantive part of the solution.” This is partly right, in that issues such as obesity, inactivity, and poor air quality lie outside the remit of health and require action from other government departments. But money is needed, and this year’s 5% reduction in the public health grant used by local authorities to run services that are directly concerned with preventing ill health (including health visiting and drug and alcohol services) is a concrete example of the mismatch between the ambition to improve prevention and the reality experienced by patients and staff in those services.
The DHSC also offers the helpful suggestion that “there is a role for GPs to advise patients” about lifestyle—perhaps being unaware that we already do this, all day, every day, in between treating heart failure, diagnosing cancers, and reassuring the worried well. It’s also worth noting that getting GPs to offer advice on exercise has been shown not to be an effective use of our time.
From this month’s @bmj.com, an astute piece by @helensalisbury.bsky.social on how the government (in this case in England, but applicable elsewhere too) needs to put its money where its mouth is when it comes to preventing ill health.
Link here:
www.bmj.com/content/388/...
15.02.2025 13:36
👍 46
🔁 18
💬 6
📌 3
#Bluesky: We provide medical assistance to people affected by conflict, epidemics, disasters or exclusion from healthcare.
Independent. Neutral. Impartial.
Thank you for sharing and following our account.
09.02.2025 18:38
👍 1218
🔁 418
💬 13
📌 6
Ja sej, zato pa gledam pa pametujem, drugače bi že kupila pa brala 😂 Pa še sigurna nisem, da bi kaj razumela. Ne vem, če je tole poljudno! 😂
08.02.2025 17:57
👍 0
🔁 0
💬 0
📌 0
Tole izgleda izredno kul. Bogve a teli arheologi rabijo kakšnega pucfleka?
08.02.2025 14:06
👍 1
🔁 0
💬 1
📌 0
END
OFLIFE
The UK spends
£11.7bn
on healthcare for people in the last year of life. For every £5 of this, £4 is spent in hospital.
Only 11%
(£1.3bn) goes to community and primary healthcare
[Marie Curie]
The @bmj.com is often a little mischievous in its news section, with bold statements and facts in large letters, but not always with links to the source.
I’ve checked the Marie Curie website and here’s a link to more information:
www.mariecurie.org.uk/blog/public-...
#EOLC
#EndOfLifeCare
#MedSky
08.02.2025 10:35
👍 6
🔁 1
💬 2
📌 0
Abstiniraj, liverina pa ne jej, kristusbuhintito. Nobene koristi za jetra, večkrat pa vidna škoda. Jaz to najprej vprašam pri povisanih jetrnih testih. A) alkohol in b) prehranski dodatki. Sicer pa držim pesti za uspešno nižanje!
06.02.2025 11:55
👍 12
🔁 0
💬 2
📌 0
Quick reminder that if you see a headline from a source you’ve never heard of that isn’t being reported by anyone else, you really should do some due diligence before spreading it around as fact. There’s enough misinformation floating around already; no need to add more.
01.02.2025 14:04
👍 17232
🔁 2650
💬 274
📌 123
Val 202 ukinja sporne oglasne oddaje
Kot napoveduje direktor Radia Slovenija, bo te
Oglasne "oddaje", v katerih podjetja praviloma predstavljajo različna prehranska dopolnila, se bodo v februarju poslovile s programa enega najbolj poslušanih slovenskih radiev.
28.01.2025 08:59
👍 26
🔁 3
💬 2
📌 0
Another reminder:
Respiratory infections spread mainly through the air. That’s why they affect the lungs.
Masks, worn correctly and consistently, reduce the spread of respiratory infections.
Respirators work better than masks.
Washing hands isn’t wrong, but it won’t stop airborne transmission.
10.12.2024 09:56
👍 1329
🔁 487
💬 23
📌 18
Reef Highlights 2024
YouTube video by Drawaqa Marine Conservation Trust
My marine biologist son Rob has lived on the same island for 7 years, doing painstaking work to improve biodiversity and train local people in conservation. Here’s a new video. Nothing dramatic (he’s not Attenborough and doesn’t have a film crew). Just a healthy coral reef:
youtu.be/2wlk-yfYi9Q?...
01.01.2025 10:39
👍 5646
🔁 697
💬 258
📌 38
Helen Salisbury: An illusion of control
We’ve been shaken recently in our surgery by some unexpected diagnoses and sudden deaths that have reminded us of how poor doctors can be at predicting the future health of patients. With some people ...
From @helensalisbury.bsky.social in the @bmj.com this month.
“The focus on prevention that we’ve been promised in the NHS shouldn’t just be about asking patients to take control of their own health through lifestyle changes…”
Link here:
www.bmj.com/content/387/...
#PublicHealth
#SDOH
#MedSky
27.12.2024 21:50
👍 16
🔁 11
💬 3
📌 0
1/2
Haven't done this for a while, but this one matters and just maybe 🦋 is still a place for this.
DRC: 406 cases/31 deaths from an undiagnosed respiratory disease, mostly affecting children.
- lab results will take time due to regional instability, specimen collection & logistics, rainy season…
10.12.2024 21:39
👍 25
🔁 10
💬 1
📌 0
I'd love to be added. I teach family medicine at University of Ljubljana.
11.12.2024 10:59
👍 0
🔁 0
💬 0
📌 0
Ajme.
11.12.2024 10:51
👍 1
🔁 0
💬 0
📌 0
James Orbinski, former International President, delivered a speech at the Nobel Peace Prize ceremony.
25 years ago, Doctors Without Borders was honoured with the Nobel Peace Prize.
The prize proceeds were used to establish a fund dedicated to supporting efforts against neglected diseases.
Today, we remain committed to addressing some of the world’s most neglected diseases. #IDSky #MedSky
10.12.2024 15:30
👍 298
🔁 52
💬 3
📌 2
ARSO potresi
#Potres ob 3.37 magnitude 3,5 8 km JZ od Škofje Loke. Več na potresi.arso.gov.si Ste čutili potres? Izpolnite potresi.arso.gov.si/vprasalnik
09.12.2024 03:10
👍 6
🔁 8
💬 0
📌 2
The Best Science Fiction and Fantasy Books of 2024 (Gift Article)
The year’s best speculative fiction includes a fantasy novel by Kelly Link, alien epics and promising starts to series.
My top 10 SFF of the year are up at @nytimes.com today, with one notable lacuna because I only managed to read it after I filed, so take it from me that METAL FROM HEAVEN absolutely belongs on this list & would have been if I had my shit more together, demonstrating why lists should be taken w/salt
06.12.2024 17:28
👍 415
🔁 120
💬 29
📌 19
Moje pleme... 🤦♀️
06.12.2024 22:50
👍 1
🔁 0
💬 0
📌 0
kot študentka v ameriki sem ure in ure zabila na telefonu z zdr. zavarovalnico, čakala na holdu ob možgane parajoči muziki, in se vedno znova prerekala in dokazovala, da so mi dolžni kriti 30 $ za recept. skoraj vsak mesec eno in isto. nekajkrat celo 2-3krat za en in isti recept. 1/
05.12.2024 18:07
👍 19
🔁 3
💬 3
📌 0
Ob petkih poziram.
Lep pozdrav, 🌶
06.12.2024 05:55
👍 43
🔁 2
💬 2
📌 0
Tole je pa kar next level, a? 😳
05.12.2024 16:07
👍 5
🔁 0
💬 2
📌 0
I think it would be a good idea
05.12.2024 14:18
👍 2771
🔁 439
💬 32
📌 5
I honestly believe all LLM results should come with a disclaimer reminding people that the thing doesn’t (and absolutely cannot) know any facts or do any reasoning; it is simply designed to *sound* like it knows facts and frequently sweeps some up accidentally in the process.
04.12.2024 12:53
👍 3042
🔁 654
💬 133
📌 59
We don't need more remakes of old movies. We need more MUPPETS remakes of old movies.
02.12.2024 02:08
👍 28715
🔁 3763
💬 754
📌 403
A blood test that could spot cancer early is for sale in Canada. Would you pay $2,099 for it? | CBC News
It’s an idea that thrills cancer researchers: a blood test that has the potential to screen for a sweeping number of cancers before symptoms appear.
Blood test that can screen for 50+ cancers now for sale, at $2,099 www.cbc.ca/news/health/...
Dr Eddy Lang: "The problem as I see it is that the test has not yet been proven to improve patient outcomes."
Yep, I'm DEEPLY skeptical. Anxiety. Over-diagnosis. Iatrogenic injury. Increased costs.
30.11.2024 22:52
👍 116
🔁 24
💬 17
📌 2