Nomination Notes Wrapped
A look back at my coverage of judicial nominations in 2025.
If you're not following @patrickryne.bsky.social's Nomination Notes on Substack, why not? And then go ahead and subscribe now!! His coverage is incredible and incredibly necessary given that he's covering nominees who are up for LIFETIME appointments! open.substack.com/pub/nominati...
31.12.2025 02:39
π 1
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
patrick's POV | Patrick McNeil | Substack
Click to read patrick's POV, by Patrick McNeil, a Substack publication. Launched 7 days ago.
You all! @patrickryne.bsky.social has a brilliant new substack! He's continuing to write about judicial nominations and the impact on our civil rights, our communities, and our future! Go and subscribe now -
patrickryne.substack.com!
24.10.2025 18:06
π 1
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
DISQUALIFYING. Tung is unfit to serve in a lifetime position and should not be trusted to recognize, protect, and advance our rights.
30.07.2025 16:22
π 1
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
WOW. in response to @booker.senate.gov, 9th Circuit nominee Eric Tung repeatedly refuses to say Democrats aren't evil
BOOKER: Do you think that today's Democrats are relentless and evil?
TUNG: You're asking me to comment on a political question...I cannot & should not speculate or comment on that.
30.07.2025 16:16
π 0
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
NEW from @lzwarensteyn.bsky.social on Bove confirmation: βOur federal courts must serve and work for all of us, and they must be staffed with judges who are fair-minded, ethical, and committed to respecting our rights and upholding the law & Constitution. Emil Bove fails on each of these measures."
30.07.2025 01:08
π 3
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
The Leadership Conference Condemns Confirmation of Emil Bove
WASHINGTON β Lena Zwarensteyn, senior director of the fair courts program and an advisor at The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, issued the following statement after the Senate confirmed Emil Bove to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit:
βOur federal courts must serve and work for all of us, and they must be staffed with judges who are fair-minded, ethical, and committed to respecting our rights and upholding the law and Constitution. Emil Bove fails on each of these measures. The Senateβs confirmation of Mr. Bove to the Third Circuit is a disgrace that jeopardizes equal justice in America. His deeply inadequate judicial temperament, his unacceptable record of abusing power, and his disturbing efforts to seek retaliation while at the Justice Department should have been disqualifying. Instead, he was rewarded with a lifetime position on a powerful appellate court. Every senator who voted to confirm Mr. Bove β despite serious, troubling, and increasing whistleblower revelations and so many unanswered questions β has failed their constituents and our country. They have further undermined the independence of the federal judiciary and are complicit in all that Mr. Bove will accomplish on the bench on behalf of the president and his anti-civil and human rights agenda.
βThis is not okay. For the future of our courts and our democracy, this cannot be the new normal for the U.S. Senate. We need judges who are fair-minded and ethical, who are qualified to serve in the role, and who will treat all people respectfully and uphold the rights of all of us. Weβre grateful to the bipartisan group of senators who showed up for our democracy and opposed this nomination, and we urge all senators to take seriously their obligation to scrutinize the records of judicial nominees. The Senate can and must do better.
βTodayβs vote was shameful. History will remember.β
Lena Zwarensteyn, from the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, issued the following statement after Bove's confirmation.
It ends like this: βTodayβs vote was shameful. History will remember.β
30.07.2025 01:57
π 312
π 90
π¬ 3
π 2
A mistake?
This is a lifetime nomination. We expect that all Senators FULLY vet each and everyone one of these nominees.
24.07.2025 16:55
π 1
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Senator @booker.senate.gov on Bove nomination: "This is a time for another profile in courage. I'm hoping my Republican colleagues will look at the evidence and join in the conclusion held by so many patriots in our country and not let this man on one of the highest courts in the land."
24.07.2025 00:21
π 1
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
Sen. @booker.senate.gov "Willful ignorance does not excuse any of us from our responsibility to seek the truth...I plead with my colleagues: Look at the facts. Give it your scrutiny. Analyze this nominee. Look at his record. Emil Bove has shown...his disrespect for the very office he seeks to hold."
24.07.2025 00:12
π 4
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
Sen. @schiff.senate.gov: "He is there whenever Trump needs someone to carry out his will, regardless of ethical or even legal considerations. And dedicated public servants, career prosecutors are standing up to him, willing to risk their jobs, willing to risk retaliation by a vindictive president."
23.07.2025 23:55
π 2
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
Sen @hirono.senate.gov: "Far from an independent, fair-minded jurist, Mr. Bove is willing to use whatever means he deems necessary to meet the ends sought by Donald Trump...No question that the reason Mr. Bove came to President Trump's attention is his complete loyalty...which he manifests clearly."
23.07.2025 23:43
π 1
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
Senator @hirono.senate.gov says that Emil Bove is unfit for a lifetime judgeship given his disregard for the rule of law and his temperament. "There are so many red flags regarding this nominee...Mr. Bove has no respect for the rule of law or the courts that uphold it."
23.07.2025 23:37
π 1
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
Senator @whitehouse.senate.gov: "This is a mark my words moment about an individual who will continue to disgrace himself and the rule of law if we put him on the bench."
"The mad dash to jam through this nominee...is a new low."
23.07.2025 23:28
π 2
π 2
π¬ 1
π 0
Sen. @welch.senate.gov underscoring Emil Bove's incredible lack of judicial temperament & disrespect for the rule of law. Says he's been an "active participant in political payback" & that Trump has made clear the people he wants appointed are people who will put him and his political desires first.
23.07.2025 23:21
π 2
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
Senator @kim.senate.gov says that the people of New Jersey and the country deserve better than Emil Bove and that "the answer must be no" on his confirmation. Speaking powerfully against Bove's nomination to a New Jersey seat on the Third Circuit, hitting home Bove's fierce loyalty to Trump.
23.07.2025 23:14
π 1
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
Senator @durbin.senate.gov: "President Trump is going to continue to nominate extreme, unqualified individuals unless the Senate takes a stand...I urge my colleagues: Vote against Mr. Bove and all future nominees who are only loyal to the president and not to the Constitution."
23.07.2025 23:09
π 1
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
Senator @blumenthal.senate.gov on Trump's judicial nominees: "These nominations are unqualified...and if confirmed they'd extend the administration in its reach into the courts, in effect co-signing the president's most destructive and dangerous impulses, regardless of legality."
23.07.2025 22:49
π 1
π 1
π¬ 1
π 0
Senator Richard Blumenthal speaking on the Senate floor.
HAPPENING NOW: Senate Dems are speaking on the floor about Trump's judicial nominees. @blumenthal.senate.gov says they're discussing one of the most important decisions they're going to make with respect to the future of justice in America β the nomination of Emil Bove to serve on the Third Circuit.
23.07.2025 22:45
π 17
π 10
π¬ 2
π 0
What are Senate Republicans hiding? Rushing this vote for a LIFETIME seat?
22.07.2025 21:27
π 2
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
βI think when it comes down to it...in a lifetime position that requires good judgment, wise discretion, good temperament and the dedication to the rights of all, Mr. Bove fails on every single one of those accounts," @lzwarensteyn.bsky.social told @statesnewsroom.com.
17.07.2025 18:18
π 2
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
Bove should NOT be in a lifetime seat on our federal judiciary. What Chair Grassley forced today is appalling - the disrespect, the intentional rush and hiding of critical information, the silencing of a whistleblowerβ¦ Itβs appalling. And for a guy whose temperament alone is disqualifyingβ¦
17.07.2025 16:12
π 2
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
900 Ex-Justice Dept. Lawyers Urge Senate Not to Confirm Bove as Federal Appeals Judge
To elevate Emil Bove to a lifetime judicial appointment without fully investigating his disgraceful conduct at DOJ would violate every senator's duty to ensure we remain a nation of laws.
16.07.2025 23:44
π 23
π 11
π¬ 0
π 1
ICE Lawyers Are Hiding Their Names in Immigration Court
ICE attorneys fighting to deport immigrants are able to obscure their identities β no masks required.
Lawyers for ICE are increasingly hiding their identities in court. This is completely unprecedented.
βWeβre not really doing names publicly,β said Judge ShaSha Xu β after stating her own name and those of the immigrants and their lawyers.
theintercept.com/2025/07/15/i...
15.07.2025 17:17
π 4487
π 1911
π¬ 334
π 359
More than 75 former judges urge Senate committee to reject Trump judicial nominee Emil Bove | CNN Politics
More than 75 former federal and state judges on Tuesday called on the Senate Judiciary Committee to reject the nomination of Emil Bove, President Donald Trumpβs former personal attorney, to a prestigi...
NEW: More than 75 former judges urge Senate committee to REJECT Trump judicial nominee Emil Bove.
βMr. Boveβs egregious record of mistreating law enforcement officers, abusing power, and disregarding the law itself disqualifies him for this position,β the former judges wrote.
More: bit.ly/44OGwoq
15.07.2025 11:51
π 26
π 19
π¬ 1
π 0
We ALL need to know more before any votes to rush this guy on to a LIFETIME seat. It's the bare minimum.
No one is entitled to a lifetime position on our federal courts, and certainly not anyone who has abused power and subverted the rule of law.
Thank you, @judiciarydems.senate.gov
15.07.2025 13:19
π 0
π 0
π¬ 0
π 0
Hermandorfer Confirmation Threatens Our Rights and Democracy
The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights issued the following statement after the Senate confirmed Whitney Hermandorfer.
βOur courts must work for all of us, but the confirmation of Whitney Hermandorfer to serve in a lifetime position on the Sixth Circuit threatens our civil rights and the future of equal justice in America." Statement from @lzwarensteyn.bsky.social: civilrights.org/2025/07/14/h...
14.07.2025 22:40
π 1
π 1
π¬ 0
π 0
Numerous, high-level judges and attorneys are standing by the whistleblower who says Emil Bove, Trump's judicial nominee to the 3rd Circuit, said DOJ should ignore court orders and tell the courts "F*** you."
More: www.politico.com/news/magazin...
02.07.2025 15:57
π 4
π 4
π¬ 0
π 0