Proposal/ Reality
@jcbradbury.com
Economist, Georgian, Gadfly Stadium Subsidies, Film Incentives, Local Economic Development, Sports Economics Tariffs bad. Vaccines good. Conjecture is not evidence. jcbradbury.com Book website: ThisOneWillBeDifferent.com
Proposal/ Reality
If only there had been some sort of indication that this is exactly what would happen...
County Attorney Says Lack Of Development At Stadium Site To Hurt Taxpayers - Chattanoogan.com share.google/n3gN92vAxDpe...
Literally shouted down.
Cobb leaders shouted down Braves stadium opponents as naysayers, insisting future financial returns would prove their case. When they showed the opposite, they lied and said they were vindicated. The blind faith in stadium projects is so strong that it persists, even in hindsight.
Let me explain what's going on here. The Braves Development Co CEO and Cobb County CFO are saying that bc the blue number > red number the stadium is paying for itself. Guys, that's a big fat F on your public finance homework. This is so bad. x.com/jc_bradbury/...
The folks who zealously backed (and continue to back) this pet project are selectively reporting financial figures to make it appear that the stadium is paying back its public cost. It's not. STOP repeating these ridiculous assertions. A Twitter threads I wrote on this. x.com/jc_bradbury/...
This is so bad. The economist (me) who has studied this deal more than anyone has found that Truist Park continues to lose about the same amount of money it was always losing. Please don't counter real research with numbers from motivated bureaucrats, cooked up with the Braves.
And now Rays stadium backers are repeating a debunked booster talking point about the Truist Park/Battery project to promote the false hope that the Tampa plan will work.
Love the Tim Tucker byline.
Time is a flat circle.
What's worse is that these people are getting away with it. They're giving $1.8 BILLION of taxpayer money to a private leisure business owned by a family of nepo-babies, and the officials in charge don't even pretend to care if there is really a serious policy case for it.
The Unified Government pledged up to $450 million to repay STAR bonds for the Chiefs' new stadium based on a two-page spreadsheet and a 'best guess' analysis it has not fully explained.
I look forward to seeing this published in the Journal of Best Guess Analysis.
This "study" sure seems solid.
Wyandotte County released only two pages of a financial study backing its $450 million pledge for a Chiefs stadium, leaving key cost details unclear.
It's disgusting to see these wealthy privateers seeking to extract even more resources from local communities, while engaging it deliberate bad faith negotiations.
Correction Yesterdayβs newsletter said a bill that would eliminate property taxes on single-family primary residences had passed a committee. Lawmakers amended the bill so that it would reduce property taxes, but not eliminate them.
Whoopsies! And as best I can tell, the legislation reimburses local governments for reducing property taxes (there is no state property tax any more), but I can't tell exactly how this would work because the bill wasn't posted last time I checked.
It is impossible for government to devote $1.15 billion of public resources to build a stadium at no cost to taxpayers. www.tampabay.com/news/educati...
At the time he said the sale "has been in the works for about a year." The land swap was completed less than a year later, with certain assurances to community, yet conditions were not included in sale.
Is anyone going to bring up the controversial land swap this guy did with DeKalb County? After making numerous promises to the community, he cashed in and sold his studio without assurances that the promises would be kept.
Previously this deal had been described as including a public contribution for surrounding infrastructure (whatever that means), perhaps funded by a TIF tax, but I'm not seeing it mentioned in recent stories. Is that still happening?
Terry McGuirk
Cursed or reaping what it sows.
WTF is this paid advertisement doing in the middle of today's AJC newsletter? I know you have to make money, but this crosses a line. An uncareful reader could easily mistake this paid propaganda for an opinion promoted by the newspaper.
I wish. π
Just got an e-mail from the Savannah Bananas, and I have never marked a message as spam faster than that.
Browns owner Jimmy Haslam has a net worth approaching $9 billion, which he mostly inherited. buff.ly/y5K7FpT
Seems like the kind of starter Atlanta could have used some of its bounteous Battery money to sign.
It's a shame the PD has such shoddy leadership, because it has some good journalists on the beat. Rich Exner's coverage of stadium deals has been excellent.